Close-up of potato salad with red-skinned and Yukon Gold potato cubes tossed in a creamy dressing and parsley on a warm wooden background.

Red, Russet, or Yukon? Best Potatoes for Different Types of Potato Salad

by
Jump to Recipe

Introduction

Choosing the right potato makes or breaks your salad. Red, Russet, or Yukon Gold each gives a different bite, flavor, and look. This guide shows the best potatoes for potato salad—from waxy vs starchy potatoes to Red vs Russet vs Yukon Gold for potato salad. You’ll see which potato fits creamy mayo salads, bright vinaigrette bowls, and warm German-style dishes. So you get great texture, clean flavor, and a salad that holds up on the table and in the fridge.

For more recipes, try our:

Potato Types 101: Waxy vs. Starchy vs. All-Purpose

Red (Waxy)

Red potatoes have thin skin and a creamy bite. They hold their shape, so slices stay neat. Therefore, they shine in no-mayo vinaigrette potato salad and Mediterranean-style salads. In short, choose Reds when you want firm texture and clean, bright flavor.

Yukon Gold (All-Purpose)

Yukon Golds taste buttery and have moderate starch. They work in almost any style, from classic deli potato salad to light mustard dressings. As a result, they’re the safest pick when you want balance in waxy vs starchy potatoes.

What Is a Yukon Gold Potato?(Starchy)

Russets turn fluffy and soak up dressing fast. They make extra-creamy, deli-style bowls that many people love. However, they break easier, so mix gently. For Red vs Russet vs Yukon Gold for potato salad, choose Russet when creaminess is the goal.

Other Varieties (New, Fingerling, Kennebec/Charlotte)

New and fingerling potatoes keep a firm, glossy finish. Kennebec and Charlotte offer specialized textures that hold well in no-mayo or warm styles. So, use them when presentation matters and you need tidy slices. They’re great options in the best potatoes for potato salad playbook.

Best Potato by Salad Style (Matchmaking Guide)

Mayo/Deli-Style (American/Southern)

Pick Yukon Gold for balance and a smooth, buttery bite. It handles mayo and mustard well. For extra-creamy texture, use Russet; it absorbs dressing fast. Stir gently so chunks stay neat. This is the safest bet when choosing the best potatoes for potato salad.

German (Warm Vinegar-Bacon)

Go Red or Yukon Gold. Both hold shape when warm and still taste rich. Toss slices with vinegar while they’re hot so flavors soak in. These waxy/all-purpose picks beat Russet in warm no-mayo potato salad.

Mediterranean/Vinaigrette (No-Mayo)

Choose Red, new, or fingerling potatoes. They stay firm and glossy under olive oil and lemon. Add herbs like dill or parsley for lift. For waxy vs starchy potatoes, waxy wins here every time.

Japanese/Korean-Style

Use Yukon Gold for that mash-meets-chunk feel. Add about 20% Russet if you want extra softness. Carrots, cucumbers, and a light mayo or yogurt dressing fit well. It’s a great middle ground in Red vs Russet vs Yukon Gold for potato salad.

Loaded/Tex-Mex

Pick Yukon Gold or Red to stand up to mix-ins. Think eggs, pickles, jalapeños, corn, or beans. Fold in a mayo-yogurt-lime dressing for balance. You’ll keep structure without losing creamy comfort.

Prep & Cooking Techniques That Lock In Texture

Close-up of red-skinned and Yukon Gold potato cubes tossed in herb vinaigrette with parsley, celery, and red onion in a rustic bowl on a warm wooden table.
Red and Yukon Gold in a bright vinaigrette show how waxy vs all-purpose potatoes hold shape and shine.

Boil Whole vs. Cubed

Boil whole potatoes for fewer waterlogged crumbs. Cubed cooks faster, but cut all pieces the same size. Start in cold, salted water for even doneness. Choose whole for vinaigrette salads; use cubes for creamy deli bowls.

Heavily Salted Water

Season inside-out. Add 2–3 tsp fine sea salt per liter of water. Simmer gently. Cook to just-tender: a knife slips in with slight resistance. This simple step boosts flavor in the best potatoes for potato salad.

Cool Smart

Want firm slices? Move cooked potatoes to an ice bath. Prefer deeper flavor? Toss warm potatoes with 1–2 Tbsp vinegar or olive oil. Then chill and finish with mayo or yogurt. This method shines in no-mayo and German styles.

Peel & Cut Strategy

Keep skins on Red (waxy) for color and grip. Partial-peel Yukon Gold for a balanced bite. Peel Russet if you want extra creamy texture. Match slice thickness to dressing weight—thicker for vinaigrette, thinner for mayo. This respects waxy vs starchy potatoes.

Steam-Dry

Drain well, then return potatoes to the warm pot. Let steam escape for 2–3 minutes. The surfaces dry and grab dressing better. So your salad stays glossy, not watery, and holds up in the fridge.

Red vs. Russet vs. Yukon: Head-to-Head

Shape Hold

Reds keep clean edges and neat slices. Yukon Gold stays decent, while Russet breaks sooner. For tidy bowls and waxy vs starchy potatoes debates, Red wins.

Dressing Absorption

Russet drinks up mayo or mustard fast. Yukon absorbs well, and Red takes in less. So choose Russet when you want ultra-creamy, the best potatoes for potato salad.

Flavor Profile

Yukon tastes naturally buttery. Red brings a light, minerally-sweet note. Russet stays neutral, so dressings shine. For Red vs Russet vs Yukon Gold for potato salad, match flavor to your dressing.

Make-Ahead & Picnics

Red and Yukon resist sogginess and travel well. They hold in the fridge and on the table. Russet tastes great the same day but softens later. Therefore, pick Red/Yukon for meal prep.

Availability & Budget

Russet is usually the most affordable. Yukon and Red can cost more and shift with season or region. When budget matters, go Russet; when texture matters, weigh cost against performance.

Pro Tips

Outdoor summer lunch scene with red-skinned and Yukon Gold potato salad in herb vinaigrette, served in a stoneware bowl on a wooden table with iced tea and a fork.
Sunlit red + Yukon potato salad in a bright vinaigrette—proof that waxy and all-purpose potatoes hold shape and shine on hot days.

Salt Your Water Right (2–3 tsp per liter)

Start in cold water and add 2–3 teaspoons of fine sea salt per liter. The salt moves into the potato, so every bite tastes seasoned. This simple step boosts flavor for any style—mayo, vinaigrette, or warm. It’s essential when choosing the best potatoes for potato salad.

Cook to Just-Tender (Gentle Simmer)

Bring to a gentle simmer and test near the end. A knife should slide in with slight resistance—not mushy. Stop there, then drain. This protects shape in Red vs Russet vs Yukon Gold for potato salad and keeps chunks neat.

Steam-Dry Before Dressing (2–3 Minutes)

After draining, return potatoes to the warm pot. Let steam escape for 2–3 minutes. Surfaces dry, so dressings cling better and the salad won’t water out. This move is clutch for no-mayo vinaigrette potato salad.

Two-Stage Dressing (Warm Toss, Then Finish)

While potatoes are warm, toss with 1–2 Tbsp vinegar or olive oil. Chill, then fold in mayo or yogurt right before serving. You get deep flavor plus a clean, glossy finish. It’s a smart path in the waxy vs starchy potatoes playbook.

Mix Varieties for Texture (70:30 Red:Yukon + ~20% Russet)

Blend types for balance. Go 70% Red + 30% Yukon for shape and creaminess. Add ~20% Russet if you want extra silky bites. This combo hedges your bets across styles and keeps your potato salad photo-ready.

Red-skinned and Yukon Gold Potato Salad

Close-up of red-skinned and Yukon Gold potato cubes in a herb vinaigrette, sprinkled with parsley in a rustic bowl on a warm wooden table.

Red-skinned and Yukon Gold Potato Salad

Bright, no-mayo potato salad for 4 using red-skinned and Yukon Gold potatoes. Boil to just-tender, steam-dry, splash with vinegar while warm, then toss with olive-oil Dijon vinaigrette, celery, red onion, and parsley. Firm, glossy cubes with balanced, buttery flavor—perfect make-ahead side for summer lunches.
Print Recipe Pin Recipe
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 20 minutes
Chill Time 30 minutes
Total Time 1 hour 5 minutes
Servings: 4
Course: brunch, dinner, lunch
Cuisine: Mediterranean
Calories: 360
Ingredients Method

Ingredients
  

  • 1 kg 2.2 lb potatoes, half red-skinned + half Yukon Gold, scrubbed
  • 2 –3 tsp fine salt for boiling water
  • 2 ribs celery small dice
  • ½ small red onion or 3 scallions, finely chopped
  • 2 –3 tbsp chopped parsley or dill
  • Vinaigrette: 5 tbsp extra-virgin olive oil 3 tbsp red wine vinegar (or 2 tbsp + 1 tbsp lemon juice), 1 tsp Dijon, ½ tsp salt, ¼ tsp black pepper, 1 small garlic clove minced (optional)

Method
 

  1. Boil: Put whole potatoes in cold salted water. Simmer until just tender (knife slips in), 15–20 min.
  2. Steam-dry: Drain. Return to warm pot 2–3 min to let steam escape.
  3. Cut: When cool enough, cut into bite-size chunks (peel Yukon partly if you like).
  4. Season warm: Splash 1 tbsp vinegar over warm potatoes; toss.
  5. Mix-ins: Fold in celery, onion, and herbs.
  6. Dress: Whisk vinaigrette. Pour over potatoes and toss gently to coat.
  7. Finish: Taste for salt/pepper. Chill 30–60 min; toss again before serving.

FAQs

1) What are the best potatoes for potato salad?

Yukon Gold for most styles, Red (waxy) for vinaigrette/no-mayo, and Russet for ultra-creamy deli bowls.

2) Waxy vs starchy potatoes—what’s the difference?

Waxy (Red, new, fingerling) hold shape and stay glossy. Starchy (Russet) turn fluffy and soak up dressing fast.

3) Which potatoes work best for German potato salad?

Use Red or Yukon Gold. They hold neat slices and absorb warm vinegar-bacon dressing.

4) What should I use for no-mayo/vinaigrette potato salad?

Go Red, new, or fingerling. They stay firm under olive oil, lemon, and herbs.

5) What’s best for classic mayo/deli-style potato salad?

Choose Yukon Gold for balance. Pick Russet if you want an extra-creamy texture.

Conclusion

Here’s the rule of thumb. Red = firm and glossy. Yukon = balanced and buttery. Russet = ultra-creamy. Match the potato to the dressing style, then manage heat and cooling. Simmer to just-tender. Steam-dry. Finish with a smart, two-stage toss. You’ll get bold flavor, clean texture, and a salad that looks great on the table and in the fridge. This is your shortcut to the best potatoes for potato salad—and a clear win in Red vs Russet vs Yukon Gold and waxy vs starchy potatoes debates.

For more recipes, try our:

Leave a Comment

Recipe Rating